Reflections on the magic mirror: An ancient Asian curiosity continues to puzzle us

by Scot, Morris

Omni

Vol. 16 No. 11 Sep. 1994

P.96

Copyright by Omni


The mirror below is one of the strangest objects I've ever seen. On the back is a raised design, as shown, but the front is a bronze disc 7 centimeters in diameter, polished smooth and slightly convex, and it reflects light just as a good mirror should. There appears to be nothing unusual about it. But if you aim the mirror at the sun and cast its reflection on a wall, you'll see an image of the Buddha (right). The mirror was made in China in a process whose roots date back to the Han dynasty (100 B.C.). Typically, the molten bronze is poured into a mold that creates a picture in relief on the back of the mirror. The same image appears on the wall. Seeing the result must have seemed like magic hundreds of years ago. The Chinese called this a "light-penetrating mirror," because they believed light had to go through the surface to reflect off the back of the mirror! Mirrors similar to these but made in Japan were first seen in the West in 1832. It took a full century, but Sir William Bragg, a British crystallographer, finally published the accepted scientific explanation in The Universe of Light in 1933. The pattern in relief on the backside provides the key to the reflected image by creating areas on the disc where the thickness of the bronze varies, Bragg said. When the mirror-makerscratches and scrapes the surface to smooth it, "the thinner parts of the mirror bend and give to the tool more than the thicker parts which lie over the prominences of the pattern. When the pressure has passed, the thin parts recover and rise slightly above the average level of the face," becoming more convex than the thicker portions. The imperceptible irregularities on the front cause the image in the reflection. The same explanation was accepted by Joseph Needham, author of Science and Civilization in China (1962); by Robert K. G. Temple in China: Land of Discovery (1986); and most recently by Derek Swinson, a physicist at the University of New Mexico, writing in the May 1992 issue of The Physics Teacher. The problem is that my magic mirror doesn't work that way. The design on the back is a circle of Chinese zodiac symbols, not a Buddha. The back-side has nothing whatever to do with the image cast on the wall. Ron Edge of the University of South Carolina's department of physics and astronomy examined a mirror like this one and agrees that accepted explanations are "definitely wrong." He and a student, Tom Brouckson, directed a fine beam of light at it and determined that the face was covered with very slight ridges (rather than indentations), each with a slope of only 0.1 degree to the rest of the surface, so they' reinvisible to the naked eye. Each line of the reflected image is dark, sandwiched between two bright lines, as we would expect from a ridge. The disc's slight convexity is important because it magnifies the reflected image and makes even minor irregularities visible. James Dalgety of Britain, who obtains these mirrors from China, has theorized that the zodiac signs were added to the backs, over the Buddha design. to mislead people and to keep secret what the reflection will be. Edge thinks the Buddha ridges were cast on the face of the mirror and then polished down until they just vanish. I tend to believe that either these mirrors are made a whole new way or perhaps that Western science, from Bragg onward, has been fooled by a deliberate trick played by the ancient bronzeworkers--who made the backs match the images cast only to give the false impression that the one caused the other. (I'll expand on this next month after presenting another Chinese bronze mystery, the "spouting washbasin.") Dalgety will sell these mirrors for $75, postpaid, and will accept checks in U.S. dollars from U.S. banks. Write: Enigma Designs, James Dalgety, Manmead, N. Barrow, Yeovil, Somerset, United Kingdom BA22 7LZ. ff he receives a lot of orders, he'll have to obtain more mirrors from China, and it could take two or three months to fulfill all orders. PHOTOS: On the back of the Magic Mirror (left) is a raised design. On the front is a disc of polished bronze that seems to be an ordinary mirror--until you reflect sunlight off of it. Then, the Buddha appears (above).