The Buddhist Heritage

Reviewed by Collett Cox

The Journal of the American Oriental Society

Vol.112 No.4

Oct-Dec 1992

p.666-668

Copyright by American Oriental Society


 
 

                                            This book is a collection of papers that, for the most part, were              originally delivered as part of a symposium of the same name held in              1985 at the School of Oriental and African Studies of the University              of London. According to the editor's "Preface," this volume is the              first volume in a projected series entitled Buddhica Britannica              intended to embrace studies on various aspects of Buddhist              traditions throughout Asia. Appropriate then for the inauguration of              this series, the subject of this first volume is the "Buddhist              Heritage" in India and in the larger Asian and Western worlds, here              amply celebrated by a highly diverse assemblage of articles              considering both scriptural and wider-ranging cultural expressions.              The initial contribution, David L. Snellgrove's "Multiple Features              of the Buddhist Heritage," also serves as a kind of introduction,              first discussing some of the significant characteristics shared by              various branches of the Buddhist tradition throughout Asia, and then              examining some changes in Buddhist practice and, in particular, the              influence of tantric developments. In addition to setting forth              certain generalizations, Snellgrove wishes to correct others,              particularly those concerning Theravada versus Mahayana, where              typically the former is seen as less ritualistic and the latter as              devaluing monastic life.              In "Aspects of Theravada Buddhism in Sri Lanka and Southeast Asia,"              Heinz Bechert sketches some of the pivotal events and factors in the              development of Buddhist religious life in Theravadin cultures. These              include the institutional changes brought about by the progressive              interaction of the original sangha with state authority, the              interplay of "great" and "little" traditions, and the impact of the              colonial period. In conclusion, Bechert refers to the problem of the              emergence of Buddhist sects, which he sees as one of the most              important and least understood factors in the development of              Buddhism. To clarify this issue, Bechert appeals to a distinction              between sects and schools, i.e., respectively disciplinary and              doctrinal differences, which he has discussed at length in other              works.              K. R. Norman, in "The Pali Language and Scriptures," systematically              and with ample documentation from primary and secondary sources              surveys the most important issues in the history of the Pali canon              including among others: the councils, the bhanaka system, oral and              written phases, linguistic developments, relationships with other              traditions, later phases of the indigenous traditions, and Western              scholarship. This paper develops topics covered in the author's Pali              Literature (1983), to which it provides an important continuation              and complement.              Building on the lifelong research of Christian Hooykaas, Anthony              Christie, in "Buddhism in Southeast Asia: an Anecdotal Survey,"              discusses the relationship between Saiva and Buddhist ritualists in              modern Bali. To his treatment, Christie contributes additional              Southeast Asian material, consideration of the issue of              vegetarianism and of the practice of constructing sand cetiyas.              In a long essay, "The Unique Features of Newar Buddhism," John K.              Locke describes and explores the background and history of the              salient characteristics of Newar Buddhism. Locke locates these              unique features not simply in Newar Buddhism's being tantric or              being "mixed up with Hinduism," but in its being "embedded in a              dominant Hindu society confined within a very small geographical              area." The expression of these unique features in the "lifestyle of              the sangha and the viharas in which they live" is examined in terms              of ritual, architecture, social history, and historical antecedents.                           E. Zurcher, in "The Impact of Buddhism on Chinese Culture in an              Historical Perspective," concisely delineates the main strands of              the history of Buddhism in China: the silk road and the geography of              transmission, the main periods, the social stratification, state              relations, and cultural vicissitudes in different periods.              In "Buddhist Monuments in China: Some Recent Finds of Sarira              Deposits," Roderick Whitfield catalogues some of the numerous finds              of sarira deposits recorded in Chinese archaeological journals from              1957 to 1988, arranged conveniently here by dynasty.              The Fang-shan Chinese stone carvings of the Buddhist canon form the              topic of Lewis R. Lancaster's "The Rock Cut Canon in China: Findings              at Fang-shan." Lancaster examines the history, archaeological              details, and significance of the stone carvings begun in the seventh              century by a monk named Ching-wan of the Chih-ch'uan monastery and              continued in Fang-shan district during the next seven centuries to              include ultimately a major portion of the Buddhist canon on 14,260              stone slabs. Containing in some cases versions of texts even earlier              than those found at Tun-huang, and largely representing a version of              the canon contemporaneous with the oldest sources for our current              editions, the Fang-shan canon, Lancaster believes, is an invaluable              source that must be used in any future critical studies of the              Chinese canon.              Youngsook Pak, in "Excavations of Buddhist Temple Sites in Korea              since 1960," surveys, with plates, excavation reports on five              important temple complexes built in Korea between the fifth and              tenth centuries. In addition, along with diagrams of groundplans, he              discusses the layout of the monasteries uncovered at these sites              with a view towards placing them in the history of sacred              architecture in East Asia during this period.              In "Word and Wordlessness: The Spirit of Korean Buddhism," Hee-Sung              Keel first presents a short overview of the basic social groups and              major personalities of Korean Buddhism. Next, the author examines              the key relationship in Korean Buddhism between Kyo (older              established doctrinal schools) and Son (Ch'an or Zen), as              exemplified in the writings of Hyujong, a central figure of the Yi              dynasty, on the relationship between verbal doctrine and ineffable              truth.              In "Contemporary Lay Buddhist Movements in Japan: A Comparison              Between Reiyukai and Soka Gakkai," Kubo Tsugunari offers a              conspectus, enriched by the knowledge and unique insights of an              insider, on this pair of lay Buddhist religious groups. Both              Reiyukai and Soka Gakkai, under the impetus of a common heritage of              Buddhist thought and, in particular, the Lotus Sutra, have              originated, expanded, and eventually flourished in modern era Japan.              Kubo first sets out the personalities and history of each movement,              succinctly situating each in its larger social context, then              describes practice and belief, and, in conclusion, summarizes their              most important similarities and divergencies.              A. Piatigorsky first presents some general observations about the              nature of religious syncretism, connected here to the specific              interaction between Buddhism and shamanism, in "Buddhism in Tuva:              Preliminary Observations on Religious Syncretism." Following this              treatment of Buddhism and shamanism, the author adds a short              chronology of Buddhism in Tuva and concludes with personal              ethnographic observations of the religious situation in Ivolga.              In "The Buddhist Notion of an 'Immanent Absolute' (tathagatagarbha)              as a Problem in Hermeneutics," D. Seyfort Ruegg traces the attempts              of the later Buddhist tradition to reconcile the notion of a              spiritual germ, matrix or Buddhanature (gotra, tathagatagarbha) with              the fundamental teaching of non-self or (anatman). One prominent              mode of reconciliation was hermeneutical: drawing upon ideas shared              with Indian poetics, Buddhist interpreters elaborated a hierarchy of              statements, in which unacceptable overt declarations could be              rendered acceptable by declaring them to be intentional surface              presentations of deeper meanings accessible only through the              requisite exegesis. For a more detailed treatment of this problem              and its solutions, both hermeneutical and doctrinal, we are referred              by the author to the first chapter of his Buddha-nature, Mind and              the Problem of Gradualism in a Comparative Perspective (School of              Oriental and African Studies, University of London, 1989).              In "Contemporary European Scholarship on Buddhism," a fitting final              contribution to this wide-ranging volume, Russell Webb surveys the              most prominent European researchers on Buddhism by area of              specialization, with background information and bibliographical              record of their publications and activities.              All scholars of Buddhism will undoubtedly find something of interest              to be read with profit in this diverse collection of papers. The              editor and the Institute of Buddhist Studies, Tring, are to be              thanked for bringing about the publication of this, and we hope              future volumes of the Buddhica Britannica series.